• How do chemical companies apply digital to the chem lab? Digitalization is streamlining the way companies innovate and bring products to market. Tech-Clarity's Jim Brown will share findings from his research on how chemical companies leverage the digital enterprise to improve efficiency and reduce cost while dealing with mounting regulatory and sustainability pressure.Register for the December 13 webcast (free of charge, registration required). Sponsored by Dassault Systemes BIOVIA. … [ read more ]

    Digitalizing the Chemical Lab (webcast)
  • This Tech-Clarity TV animation explains how companies can combat industry disruption from new, innovative companies and business models in the food and beverage industry by adopting the digital enterprise. It's no secret that companies like Amazon, Blue Apron, HelloFresh, and more are changing the way consumers and consumer packaged goods companies relate. This video shares how companies can become more innovative and agile to compete with these challengers through the value of digitalization, and provides an example of what a digital food and beverage company looks … [ read more ]

    Digitalization in the Food and Beverage Industry (Animation)
  • Join Tech-Clarity's Jim Brown in a lively discussion with Planview NPD Evangelist Carrie Nauyalis discussing how to effectively measure product innovation. The duo will discuss the pitfalls of measuring innovation based on prior performance, the top five measures companies can use to measure innovation capability, and what's needed to get started measuring innovation to improve outcomes.Register for the November 30th webcast now, sponsored by Planview (free of charge, registration required).  … [ read more ]

    Top 5 Metrics to Stop Measuring Innovation in the Rearview Mirror (webcast)
  • Jim Brown will moderate this IEEE webcast featuring Gentherm Director of Engineering Systems Marinko Lazanja and PTC's Senior Director of Product Management Graham Birch. The webcast will share the importance of managing Bills of Material and product structures to avoid common inefficiencies and errors, but also to serve as the digital product backbone for the digital enterprise. The webinar will be an interactive discussion focusing on the things companies should look for when evaluating a solution to support BOM Management, including:Software Requirements (functionality) Service Needs (including … [ read more ]

    Select the Right PLM Solution for BOM Management (webcast)
  • This episode of Tech-Clarity TV explores how food and beverage industry can avoid industry disruption from a new class of competitors, including the likes of Amazon, Blue Apron, HelloFresh, and others. It shares how digitalization can help R&D innovate faster, readily customize products to customer needs, and respond to the market with both agility and quality.This video is part of a series of videos showing how digitalization can help food and beverage companies compete with these innovative, digital industry competitors that are disrupting the status quo.The video series is sponsored by … [ read more ]

    Raising the Bar in R&D with Digitalization and the Digital Enterprise (video)

Driving Engineer-to-Order Differentiation and Profitability (survey findings)

Share

Driving Engineer-to-Order Differentiation and Profitability, Analyzing Trends and Best Practices in Product ConfigurationETO-Survey-Thumb shares survey findings and interviews with leading manufacturers showing how Top Performers achieve higher revenue and profit margin growth through ETO best practice processes and technology. The research shares results of a survey of over 200 manufacturers and analyzes their use of product configurators and automation technology to improve estimation, quote, design, documentation, and manufacturing performance.

Please enjoy the summary below or click the report to download a PDF overview (free of charge, no registration required).

For the full report, please visit our sponsor Siemens PLM (free of charge, registration required).

Executive Overview

Customized products are more compelling to customers and drive higher profitability. They can also create chaos in sales proposal and order fulfillment processes as engineers scramble to develop cost estimates, customized designs, and detailed manufacturing and sales documentation. This engineer-to-order (ETO) study finds that some companies have found better ways to design custom products, alleviating the engineering bottleneck created in most companies when quotes requests or orders roll in.

The manufacturing industry needs to adopt best practices and technology to accommodate the growth in customized products. Researchers for this report surveyed over 200 companies, finding that product customization is growing significantly. Why? For some companies, it helps them differentiate. For others, their industry doesn’t give them a choice. It’s just the nature of the business. Either way, growth in product customization drives increased complexity that leads to late deliveries, recalls / warranty work, and missed financial targets. The cause? Manual processes for custom products make Engineering a bottleneck to getting quotes and orders out of the door.

Fortunately Tech-Clarity research1 shows that companies taking more advanced ETO approaches to customize their products end up with better results. This report investigates trends in customization and digs deeper into these best practices. The analysis finds that manufacturers achieving the highest sales and profitability growth, The Top Performers, place more strategic emphasis on rapid quote and order turnaround. They also perform better when executing orders, experiencing significantly fewer errors.

Our research shows that Top Performers adopt leading design practices including platform, modular, and rules-based design techniques1. Survey reports show they support these best practices with leading technologies, finding that they are:

  • More than twice as likely to use technical product configurators
  • 53% more likely to have quote automation
  • 22% more likely to leverage design automation

This research concludes that customization performance can be improved with ETO best practices and technologies. These approaches help Top Performers relieve engineering bottlenecks, leading to better order performance and financial results.

Table of Contents

  • Executive Overview
  • Product Customization is on the Rise
  • Understanding Customization Business Drivers
  • Creating Differentiation in Customized Products
  • Taking A Deeper Look at Customization
  • Recognizing Customization Challenges
  • Recognizing Potential Negative Impacts of Customization
  • Identifying the Top Performers
  • Analyzing what Top Performers do Differently
  • Evaluating Top Performers’ Process Advantages
  • Analyzing the Technical Enablers of Top Performers
  • Identifying the Technical Capabilities of Top Performers
  • Conclusion
  • Recommendations
  • About the Author
  • About the Research
  • Footnote

Conclusion

ETO-Survey-2016-Figure_1_ExtractProduct customization is growing and is expected to continue to grow. Customization provides significant business value, but also brings significant challenges. These challenges result in a large percentage of orders with costly and time-consuming mistakes. Top Performers, however, have fewer order errors than others. One of the key differences between their approaches and the Others’ is that they have adopted more engineering automation. ETO automation helps eliminate engineering bottlenecks and manual processes that lead to delays and errors. “If it’s done right, engineering becomes a nonfactor for leadtimes,” explains Price Mechanical’s Rogers.

Some of the key enablers that Top Performers employ more than Others are technical product configurators, design automation, MBOM generation, quote generation, and CAD automation. “The whole idea is to automate a process to allow someone to do something more value-added for the business,” explains Mark Rogers of Price Mechanical. “Automation allows engineers to design new things or cost-down products instead of processing orders.” These technologies help relieve the engineering bottleneck for customized orders and are likely the source of Top Performers enhanced order execution and higher financial performance. Other commonly used technologies including CAD, sales (CPQ) configurators, ERP, and spreadsheets also provide value, but they aren’t correlated with the Top Performers’ better performance.

Recommendations

Based on industry experience and research for this report, Tech-Clarity offers the following recommendations:

  • Focus on speed as a differentiator for customized products
  • Adopt modular and platform design approaches to streamline customization
  • Recognize the different capabilities of Technical Product Configurators and Sales (CPQ) Configurators, using each for their strengths (and possibly in combination)
  • Leverage technical product configurators and design automation to remove manual engineering effort that creates bottlenecks and results in errors in sales and order engineering processes

Adopt MBOM and quote generation capabilities to improve custom order performance

SPEAK YOUR MIND

  1. Thanks Jim for sharing and describing an important trend for future survival of companies I believe. I tried to download this interesting report., however the Siemens registration does not seem to work (for me)

    • Hi Jos,
      The link to the Siemens site wasn’t working yesterday, but I corrected it late last night (thanks to Ryan McVay for pointing out the issue).

      Are you able to the Siemens registration page at all? I have heard that their link might not be active (although the page displays).

      Let me know what’s happening and we’ll get it resolved. I’ll make sure you get the report one way for another!

      All the Best,
      Jim

      • Hi Jim, thanks for your response.

        I was able to register (meanwhile I have done it 3 times) but after pressing the button the registration page comes up again (empty) – one more step to fix it seems

Speak Your Mind

*